Younger pipe smoker (30). Been Smokin since approximately 2017. My flavor profile leans more toward Burley and Virginia. I like English and Balkan blends just fine, especially during the winter, but they're not my go-to. Perique does not sit well with me, so I have to take it sparingly. Unfortunately, this prevents me from reviewing/tasting many popular blends including a what's considered THE category of blends for some smokers with Va/Pers. I'm also not too big on overly topped blends as a general rule and love a more "natural" smoke if I can find one. I have some exceptions to this rule, but I actually like to taste the tobacco. I find Virginias can burn a bit to hot on their own, so flake Va/Burs are probably my best bet, but I've yet to try any. I'm curious about Var/Orientals and haven't had much of a chance to taste natural orientals without the addition of Latakia or Perique. There's my flavor preference if you're curious.
Burley: To me this is tobacco. Cool and dry with thick smoke and a good bit of nicotine, but not too much.
Virginia: This is just as much tobacco as burley, and it'd probably be my favorite type, but the smoke is too hot and too weak some times. I think burley compliments Virginia the most for the type of smoke I enjoy.
Cavendish: I could take or leave this type. Cav is such a nebulous term nowadays that it almost doesn't mean anything specific anymore.
Dark Fired: Love this type of blend, but on rare occasions. Not an all-day, everyday smoke for me. Kinda like taking Virginia and making it smokey and meaty.
Turkish/Oriental: A lot of variety. I haven't tried much of this on its own, but I usually enjoy it in English/Balkan blends. Looking forward to trying some more of this on its own.
Latakia: I view this as a nice condiment to have on occasion. I neither love it nor hate it.
Perique: Unfortunately I can't stomach perique. I'm highly sensitive to it and it pretty much ruins any blend I find it in, even if it's just a pinch. The only kind of tobacco I actively avoid. I've tried to develop a taste for it. I wish I liked this more since it shows up in so many highly praised and critically lauded blends.
TL;DR: I love Burley and can't stomach Perique. Virginia is rock solid but burns hot. Everything else is ornamental.
|Motivator||Has upvoted at least 80% of the time.|
95 helpful votes
4 star: 12 Strongly Recommended
3 star: 17 Recommended
2 star: 4 Somewhat Recommended
1 star: 2 Not Recommended
|2022-09-16||McClelland - No. 2005 University||2||0||2.5|
|2022-09-07||Peterson - Hyde Park||96||2||2.9|
|2022-09-06||McClelland - No. 2020 Matured Cake||53||0||3.2|
|2022-08-05||Cornell & Diehl - Sun Bear Mountain Flower (Small Batch)||8||3||3.8|
|2022-08-01||Cornell & Diehl - Blockade Runner||69||0||2.9|
|2022-04-25||Samuel Gawith - Kendal Cream Deluxe Flake||165||3||3.0|
|2021-03-19||Samuel Gawith - Hansom Flake||17||0||2.8|
|2021-01-07||Cornell & Diehl - Golden Days of Yore||28||3||2.5|
|2020-11-03||Cornell & Diehl - Christmas Blend 2016 (Corn Cob Pipe and A Button Nose)||31||2||3.0|
|2020-10-11||Cornell & Diehl - Autumn Evening||286||1||2.9|
|2020-10-09||Cornell & Diehl - Miskatonic Mixture (The Old Ones)||7||5||3.1|
|2020-10-02||Sutliff Tobacco Company - Pumpkin Spice||26||1||2.7|
|2020-10-01||Cornell & Diehl - Nutty Irishman||31||2||2.6|
|2020-09-27||Lane Limited - Captain Black Gold||205||1||2.1|
|2020-09-27||Peter Stokkebye - Norwegian Blend (No.80)||27||2||3.0|
|2020-05-17||Bengal Slices - Bengal Slices (re-release)||62||1||3.3|
|2020-04-22||Cornell & Diehl - Briar Fox||172||3||3.0|
|2020-04-20||Seattle Pipe Club - Plum Pudding||180||4||3.5|
|2020-04-16||Cornell & Diehl - Star of the East||102||3||3.1|
|2020-04-13||Lane Limited - 1-Q||380||5||2.8|
|2020-04-12||Hearth & Home - WhiteKnight (Marquee Series)||83||7||3.4|
|2020-04-12||Hearth & Home - Black House (Marquee Series)||107||2||3.6|
|2020-04-10||Peter Stokkebye - English Luxury (No.17)||75||4||3.0|
|2020-04-05||Peter Stokkebye - Luxury Bullseye Flake (No. 403)||295||2||3.3|
|2020-04-05||G. L. Pease - Maltese Falcon (Heirloom Collection)||162||3||3.2|
|2020-04-05||Cornell & Diehl - Haunted Bookshop||265||5||2.8|
|2020-04-01||Lane Limited - Captain Black Copper||29||3||3.3|
|2019-08-21||Mac Baren - HH Old Dark Fired||233||3||3.6|
|2019-08-15||Scandinavian Tobacco Group (STG) - Sir Walter Raleigh||251||7||2.8|
|2019-08-15||pipesandcigars.com - Fire Storm (RO Series)||27||1||3.8|
|2019-07-28||East India Trading Co. - Royal Challenge||13||2||2.6|
|2019-06-15||Peter Stokkebye - Luxury Twist Flake (No. 402)||216||3||3.2|
|2019-02-04||John Middleton, Inc - Carter Hall||440||3||3.0|
|2018-10-30||Lane Limited - Captain Black Royal||235||6||2.6|
|2018-10-05||Lane Limited - Captain Black Original (Regular)||493||3||2.5|